Priced Off One Comp, Negotiated With Five: How Luka Gribenko Saved Edina Buyers $30,000Reading Time: 3 minutes

Edina, MN neighborhood banner for a Kerby & Cristina buyer success story

Every list price is a story someone is telling about a home. The question is whether the data backs it up.

That’s the question one Edina couple needed answered after eight months of searching, and it’s why we want to share this win from our agent Luka Gribenko.

The Situation

These buyers had their hearts set on Edina the entire time. After eight months of looking, they walked through an open house and found the one. They wanted to make an offer right away.

There was a catch. The home was priced aggressively, and the buyers were stuck between two risks: overpay for the home they loved, or push too hard and lose it.

Most buyers in that spot make the same mistake. They let excitement set the number. Luka didn’t.

The Move

Luka went to the home the same day. He walked it himself and flagged the items likely to come up in an inspection, along with the points that could be used in negotiation, all before an offer was written.

Then he built the real picture with a full CMA. He also asked the listing agent one direct question: which comps did you use to price this home?

The answer was one sale.

Luka had about five comparable sales, and they told a very different story about where the home actually belonged. With the buyers on board, they went in with a low offer backed by data.

The Negotiation

What followed was ten days of back and forth, including many evenings that ran until 11:30 PM.

Through every round, Luka kept the conversation on facts:

  • The comps. He kept putting five sales next to the one the price was built on.
  • The market’s response. The home had not received any other offers.
  • The offer itself. He worked with the buyers on a clean, well-written offer, not just a low one.
  • The sellers’ situation. His research showed the sellers had already bought another home and needed to sell quickly.

     

The creative piece came at the end. Luka sat down with the buyers and asked what mattered more to them: a lower price or seller concessions? Then he showed them how to structure the offer so the sellers netted more on paper while the buyers still saved significantly. It gave the sellers a reason to say yes.

The Result

Between a price reduction and seller concessions, the buyers got $30,000 off list price.

A long search ended with the right home at the right price. It started with a number built on one comp, and it ended with a deal built on five.

What This Means If You're Buying in a Competitive Market

A few things worth taking away from this one:

  • A list price is the seller’s opinion. Comps tell you what a home is actually worth. Ask what the price is based on.
  • No other offers means leverage. In today’s more balanced market, a home that isn’t drawing competition gives you real negotiating room.
  • Price and concessions are two levers, not one. The right structure can save you more while netting the seller more.
  • Facts beat pressure. Every point that moved this deal came back to data.
  • You need an agent who will stay in it. Ten days and a few late nights is what it can take to get the number right.

Thinking About Buying in Edina or Anywhere in the Twin Cities?

Whether you’ve been searching for eight months or you’re just getting started, Luka and the rest of our team know how to read your submarket, build the case, and fight for the right number. For more ways to stretch your budget, read our guide to working the magic on home buying affordability.